‘Bachelor in Paradise’ stars (from left) Will Urena, Kylee Russell and Olivia Lewis.Photo:ABC/Craig Sjodin

Will Urena, Kylee Russell and Olivia Lewis

ABC/Craig Sjodin

“I’m definitely excited for a fresh start,” Rachel, 27, said in an on-camera interview.

“If it was him down on one knee, I’d be ready to say ‘yes,’” said Kylee, 25.

Jesse thought Kylee might be getting ahead of herself. “Social media’s the only interaction you’ve had with this man?” he asked. Kylie confirmed that yes, they’d only interacted online.

To Aaron, 30, and Sean’s disappointment,Charity’s first impression rose recipientBrayden Bowersrolled in next.

“Vibes just depleted,” Sean, 26, said to Aaron when Brayden, 25, arrived.

The singles kept coming, with Eliza Isichei and Samantha “Sam” Jeffries fromClayton Echard’s season, Olivia Lewis from Zach’s season and Aaron Schwartzman and Peter Cappio from Charity’s season making their ways to the beach.

Blake Moynes (left) arrives on ‘Bachelor in Paradise’ with host Jesse Palmer.Craig Sjodin/ABC via Getty

BLAKE MOYNES

Craig Sjodin/ABC via Getty

Sean told Aaron B. he wanted Jessica “Jess” Girod from Zach’s season to joinParadisebecause “I want to get covered in body glitter.” The Paradise gods came through and Jess, 24, showed up, as didGreer Blitzerand Mercedes Northup from Zach’s season, plusBlake Moynes.

Blake impressed the ladies ofParadiseimmediately.  “Blake Moynes is a fine ass man,” declared Mercedes, 25.

PARADISE BEGINS

Once everyone arrived, Jesse informed the group that the men had the roses during the first week and four women would be going home. Then, the men and women split off to discuss among themselves who they wanted to get to know, and Olivia, 24, revealed she already kissed Will, 30, earlier when they were discussing sucking toes.

So Olivia felt annoyed when Kylee, in Aven’s absence, decided to ask Will on a date — and he accepted.

“Don’t mack on me and then go say yes to a date,” Olivia complained in an interview.

The date didn’t get off to a great start — Will slipped and fell into the pool on which he and Kylee were going to be dining.

Rachel Recchia on ‘Bachelor in Paradise’.Craig Sjodin/ABC via Getty

RACHEL RECCHIA

Sean and Rachel kissed after chatting on a daybed, as did Jess and Blake. And Kylee quickly started falling for Will.

“He’s everything and more that I would ask for in a guy,” Kylee said in an interview.

Will felt similarly, telling her, “I haven’t felt like this in a whole, and it feels good.”

To the cameras, he added, “I am definitely falling for Kylee a little faster than I expected.”

Still grumpy about Will going on a date, Olivia told bartenderWells Adams, “At the end of the day, she got to taste me I don’t got to taste her.”

The next morning, Will decided to talk to Olivia about where he stood.

“I feel like there is no respect right now,” she said to Will. “I feel like this is you cleaning up the disrespect that you kind of laid out. I think there was a lot of disrespect because there was no consideration had.”

Will apologized, but thought he really didn’t need to this early in the process.

“It’s day one and you’re here to explore your options,” Will said. “I’m here to explore my options. And I also don’t think just because I give you a kiss, I owe you an explanation on day one. If it was a little bit further, deeper in the process, and we had a stronger connection, I could see why I owe you an explanation.”

“A lot of my conversation with Kylee was about real life matters, and for that, I feel like my heart is leaning a little bit more towards Kylee,” he said to Olivia.

“Then don’t grab my face and kiss me, Will!” Olivia reacted.

To complicate matters more, Kylee’s original No. 1 Aven showed up with a date card, butBachelorNation have to wait until next week to see what chaos that caused.

Never miss a story — sign up forPEOPLE’s free daily newsletterto stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

Bachelor in Paradiseairs Thursdays at 9 p.m. ET on ABC.

source: people.com